Bio Oil vs Dermatix – Which is Best?

Scars from acne, cuts, bruises, scratches, or wounds may take forever to fade. While some scars are small and unnoticeable, others could be so conspicuous that they affect your self-esteem. Such scars are prompt you to look for products that can eradicate them.

Luckily, there are skincare solutions that can help erase these scars including Bio Oil and Dermatix. Both of these products have been designed to reduce the appearance of scars through the ingredients in their formulas, as well as help manage skin related issues.

Below we make a deep dive assessment of what these two products entail in a bid to shed light on which of the two is the better product. Read on to find out…


What is Bio Oil? What is Dermatix?

Bio Oil is a light orange cosmetic oil that is formulated using a blend of botanical oils that are rich in vitamins. It is lightweight and absorbs easily in the skin without leaving a greasy feel. Its main purpose is to improve the appearance of flat scars.


Dermatix is a relatively new product in the market. It is a topical silicone gel that is used for treatment and prevention of hyper-trophic scars and keloids. It is ideal for wounds that have freshly healed such as those from surgical procedures, burns, and trauma wounds.


Bio Oil Ingredients Dermatix Ingredients
  • Calendula– this oil is extracted from a plant commonly known as pot marigold. In a study by the Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care, calendula ointment was found to increase the speed of cesarean wound healing.
  • Vitamin E– this vitamin is always prescribed after surgery for scar prevention and treatment. A review study by the Aesthetic Surgery Journal points out that Vitamin E is widely used for scar prevention, there is insufficient evidence showing that it has significant beneficial effect on scar appearance.


  • Cyclic and polymeric silicones– topical self-drying silicone gel is used as an alternative treatment to silicone gel sheeting. According to studies in the Journal of Cutaneous Aesthetic Surgery silicone gel was reported to reduce texture by 86%, color by 84%, and height by 68%.
  • Vitamin C– also known as ascorbic acid, this vitamin has significant benefits on skin health including wound healing. In a comparative study in Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, subjects were asked to use topical silicone gel containing vitamin C. The patients reported improved appearance of fine surgical scars.


How Bio Oil Works How Dermatix Works

Bio Oil harnesses the power of botanical oils and vitamins to nourish and treat acne scars. The vitamins present help to exfoliate the skin thus accelerating the healing process. As for the botanical oils, they deliver their anti-inflammatory properties to reinforce scar healing.


Dermatix contains silicone gel which is effective in the treatment of both hypertrophic and keloidal scars. Silicone gel facilitates the healing process by moisturizing the stratum corneum. This helps to increase fibroblast production while reducing collagen production. Due to this, the scar becomes breathable, softer, and flatter.


The Advantages of Bio Oil The Advantages of Dermatix
  • May improve the appearance of both new and old scars
  • May fade the appearance of stretch marks
  • May improve the appearance of uneven skin tone
  • May help tone and smooth aging skin
  • May retain the skin’s moisture


  • May soften and flatten raised scars
  • May improve the appearance of red or dark scars
  • May provide relief to discomforts of scars such as itching
  • May maintain the skin’s moisture levels
  • You can apply makeup over this product
The Disadvantages of Bio Oil The Disadvantages of Dermatix
  • Not for use on broken or bleeding skin
  • May cause breakouts on users with sensitive skin
  • May worsen acne breakouts in some individuals
  • Works best on scars that are less than 2 years old.
  • Should be applied on dry intact skin only
  • May stain clothing if not completely dry
Summary About Bio Oil Summary About Dermatix
Bio Oil is a well-formulated product that contains essential oils and vitamins to help improve the appearance of flat scars. It can be used on the face and can lock in moisture on the skin without clogging pores. The best thing about this product is that it is suitable for all skin types.  Dermatix is a product that is formulated with silicone gel to improve the appearance of raised scars. It is recommended for healed wounds that are still fresh which is from 3 months to 2 years. Dermatix also contains to improve the appearance of flat scars.


You can also read our comparison for Olay Regenerist and Boots No.7


To conclude, we can agree that both Bio Oil and Dermatix are important products for improving the appearance of scars. While Bio Oil works for flatter scars, Dermatix focuses on raised scars. This is not to say that Dermatix cannot work on flatter scars because it can lighten the scar.

Bio Oil works effectively on acne scars and stretch marks. Dermatix on the other hand can work on acne scars, burn scars, keloid scars, and hyper-trophic scars. However, it does not work on stretch marks.

Therefore, if your intention is to improve the appearance of stretch marks, Bio Oil can work better. But if you want to reduce the appearance of raised scars or burn scars, Dermatix is the product for you.



The impact of calendula ointment on cesarean wound healing: a randomized controlled clinical study:

The role of topical vitamin E in scar management: a systematic review:

The efficacy of silicone gel for the treatment of hypertrophic scars and keloids:

Improved scar appearance with combined use of silicone gel and vitamin c for Asian patients: a comparative study series:

Be the first to comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.