Neutrogena vs Oil of Olay – [Ingredients and Reviews Compared] – Which is Best?

Neutrogena and Oil of Olay are renowned skincare brands that have been around for ages. Whether you shop from drugstores or online stores, these two brands will not miss among the top brands.

Although they are not overpriced as luxurious brands such as Crème de la Mer, products by Neutrogena and Olay are also not cheap.

These two skincare giants offer consumers a wide range of products for different skin types and issues. And while most of the products are similar, Neutrogena appeals to consumers of various age groups whereas Oil of Olay mostly targets consumers with older skin.

According to dermatologists and other skin experts, Neutrogena and Olay are affordable skincare brands that are also effective. In this article, we provide you with a side by side comparison of both brands.

What is Neutrogena? What is Oil of Olay?
Neutrogena is a skincare brand that claims to be dermatologist recommended. It offers products such as cleansers, toners, moisturizers, targeted treatments, devices, and body products. It also features products for skin concerns such as acne, dark spots, and under eye puffiness.


Oil of Olay is a skincare brand that first began as a skin product for older ladies keen to look younger. The company features anti-aging products, acne products, moisturizers, body products, and many more. In recent years, Olay has expanded its target to include younger individuals as well.
Neutrogena Ingredients Oil of Olay Ingredients
  • Salicylic acid– this is a beta-hydroxy acid that works to enhance normal keratinization, decrease inflammation, and reduce sebum production as per a research study by the Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology. According to the journal, 0.5 to 5% salicylic acid is the best concentration for treating acne.


  • Ethylhexyl palmitate– this ingredient, also known as octyl palmitate, is a mixture of fatty alcohol and palmitic acid as per the International Journal of Toxicology. It works as both an emollient and a texture enhancer and according to the Cosmetic Ingredient Review, it is a safe cosmetic ingredient.
  • Niacinamide– this is a form of vitamin B3. It is an essential nutrient that supports that offers skin benefits. According to a clinical trial in the Dermatologic Surgery journal, niacinamide was found to reduce fine lines and wrinkles, dark spots, redness, sallowness, and elasticity.


  • Palmitoyl pentapeptide-4– this is a synthetic ingredient that is designed to stimulate collagen production thus provides anti-wrinkle benefit. In a self-assessment study by the International Journal of Cosmetic Science, subjects who applied this ingredient topically reported significant improvement in fine line and wrinkle appearance.
How Neutrogena Works How Oil of Olay Works
Neutrogena products can be used in a full skincare routine. The non-soap facial cleansers help rid the face of impurities and dirt. As for the daily moisturizers with sunscreen, they hydrate the skin and protect it from harmful UV rays. For nighttime, there are nighttime moisturizers that offer hydration all through the night.


Oil of Olay products also range from cleansers to moisturizers with sunscreen. These products come at an affordable price yet they keep the skin cleansed, moisturized, and protected from UV rays and environmental pollutants. For skin issues such as acne or sensitive dry skin, there are specialized products designed to deliver relief.
The Advantages of Neutrogena The Advantages of Oil of Olay
  • May moisturize the skin throughout the day
  • May enhance skin softness and smoothness
  • May protect the skin from harmful UV rays
  • May heal and manage acne breakouts
  • May soothe dry and chapped skin



  • May provide anti-aging benefits such as anti-wrinkle effects
  • May plump the body making it look supple and youthful
  • May hydrate the skin
  • May prevent damage from harmful UV rays
  • May nourish the skin with effective ingredients such as retinol
The Disadvantages of Neutrogena The Disadvantages of Oil of Olay
  • Sunscreen products such as the Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Sunscreen may cause irritation on the skin
  • Neutrogena Oil-Free Acne Wash may cause peeling, drying, or reddening of the skin
  • Anti-wrinkle creams may not work effectively on deep and coarse wrinkles
  • Products such as the Olay Regenerist Luminous Tone Perfecting Cream may fail to fade all dark spots.
Summary About Neutrogena Summary About Oil of Olay
Neutrogena products are quite popular because of their affordability and effectiveness. This brand offers a wide array of products that you can purchase and include in your day and night skincare routine. For users with sensitive or acne-prone skin, this brand has specific products formulated just for you.


Oil of Olay has a wide range of products but is notably known for its anti-aging collection. If you are looking to fade fine lines, wrinkles, under eye circles, dark spots, age spots, and dun spots, this brand has a solution for you. However, these products are not limited to antiaging creams as there are effective cleansers and moisturizers as well for all ages.



You also read: Activated Charcoal on Face – What to Expect



There you have it, a detailed comparison of these top drugstore brands. While both brands provide almost similar products, we can comfortably say that Neutrogena provides some of the best acne products and moisturizers with sunscreen. Oil of Olay on the other hand, has the best antiaging formulas.

Therefore, you can benefit from these two brands by stocking products from both. And the good thing is they are quite affordable. So next time you go product shopping, check out for both Neutrogena and Oil of Olay products.




Skin anti-aging strategies

The efficacy of glycolic acid, salicylic acid, gluconolactone, and licochalcone A combined with 0.1% adaplene vs adaplene monotherapy in mild-to-moderate acne vulgaris:

Safety assessment of alkyl esters as used in cosmetics:

Niacinamide: a B vitamin that improves aging facial skin appearance:

Topical palmitoyl pentapeptide provides improvement in photoaged human facial skin:


Be the first to comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.